What a Difference a Year Makes
The 2024 Ravens pass defense has not been nearly as effective as the 2023 version. Let’s review:
- The Ravens have just 7 takeaways (1 per game) which is tied for 17th in the NFL after accumulating 31 in 17 games (1.8) in 2023
- Despite the loss of some key pass rushers, the team remains 4th in the NFL with 22 sacks, but the Ravens have dropped to 13th in sack rate
- Opposition yards per pass has taken a sharp turn for the worse (7.53 gross yards per play, 29th) after the Ravens led the NFL with 5.15 gross pass yards per play allowed in 2023
- Game script has played a role with some soft zone defense generated by late leads
- It’s also fair to say the Ravens have faced their most difficult run of QBs in the first 7 games
- Both frequency and quality of pressure have been worse (investigated further below)
- Results for the opposing opportunity sets have also been worse (detailed below)
I categorize each opposing pass play as Ample Time and Space (ATS), Ball Out Quick (BOQ), or Pressure. The mix of these plays in any game I define as the Opportunity Set.
Among 288 plays resulting in a pass or sack (excludes penalties, spikes) in 2024, the Ravens have allowed pass plays with:
ATS: 88 times (30.6%) for 801 yards (9.1 YPP) with 2 sacks, 2 TOs
BOQ: 100 (34.7%) for 761 yards (7.6 YPP) with 0 sacks, 2 TOs
Pressure: 100 (34.7%) for 447 yards (4.5 YPP) with 20 sacks, 3 TOs
Total: 288 (100%), 2009 yards (7.0 YPP) with 22 sacks, 7 TOs
That compares to the outstanding 2023 season with
ATS: 183 times (26.4%) for 1264 yards (6.9 YPP) with 3 sacks, 10 TOs
BOQ: 226 (32.7%) for 1353 yards (6.0 YPP) with 0 sacks, 2 TOs
Pressure: 283 (40.9%) for 650 yards (2.3 YPP) with 57 sacks, 14 TOs
Total: 692 (100%) for 3267 yards (4.7 YPP) with 60 sacks and 26 TOs
Some notes on the results:
- In the bullet points above I used gross yards because that is how NFLGSIS presents team rankings but I always use net yards in my work and those are included in the comparison of the 2 seasons.
- There has been a reduction in pressures generated in 2024 of 6.2 percentage points which has been resulted in higher rates of BOQ (by 2.0 percentage points) and ATS (+4.2 percentage points).
- That difference in quality of opportunity set explains approximately 74 yards of degradation in result (10.5 yards per game).
- If I plug in the 2024 opportunity set allowed with 2023 YPP for each category, I see a result that is 573 yards worse than a year ago. This reflects the fact the Ravens have been at least 1.6 YPP worse in each of the 3 categories.
While it’s always important to improve the pressure rate if possible, it’s the failures to convert the opportunity set adequately (from a defensive perspective) that have plagued the 2024 Ravens.
I expect the Ravens will see better results relative to 2023 (do not read “as good as”) as the prospective QB slate eases, Orr settles in as a play caller, and the team tries new scheme, but the Ravens can’t ignore personnel issues in the secondary and at safety in particular.
Since I do not believe either Marcus Williams or Eddie Jackson will be back in 2025, this is a reasonable time to trade for a safety who is on a multi-year deal or otherwise has team control past 2024.
Adult Supervision Required
During a critical matchup for AFC seeding in week 4, the Ravens led 35-10 with 7:17 remaining and both teams effectively agreed to run out the clock. The Bills replaced Josh Allen with Mitch Trubisky and passed just 2 more times while running 6 times. The Ravens removed Lamar Jackson and had Josh Johnson execute run, run, pass on 3 plays as the teams ran out the last 7:17 on just 11 plays. Despite the possibility of the game deciding the location of a playoff rematch, both coaches understood the nature and risks of the long season.
Fast forward 2 weeks to a far less important interconference contest between the Bucs and Ravens and we saw a different finish. Let’s review:
- With 3:49 to play, the Buccanneers scored to cut the Ravens lead to 17, but failed the 2-point conversion when Michael Pierce sacked Baker Mayfield
- Down 17, the Bucs needed 3 possessions
- To clarify an element of confusion, the limit of 2 onside kicks was never instituted despite being mentioned during the Ravens/Cowboys game
- The Bucs recovered an onside kick then scored to cut the lead to 10 with 2:06 remaining
- They then failed to recover the second and the Ravens ran 3 times as TB used their 3 timeouts
- The Ravens punted and Tampa Bay had the ball back with 1:34 remaining
- On the first play, TE Otton was laid out by Hamilton with a shoulder-to-shoulder hit for which Todd Bowles was visibly upset with the lack of a flag
- Just 2 plays later, Chris Godwin suffered what appeared to be a catastrophic ankle injury after fighting to convert a 3rd/17 with PM21
- After Godwin left the field on a cart, the Bucs continued to pass for the next 5 plays (18 yards) without making a serious attempt to push the ball downfield into FG range
- With 0:13 remaining, Mayfield then closed out game with a 12-yard run on which he did not slide but Hamilton mercifully held up on the tackle
By comparison to the Buffalo game, the last 7:17 required 28 plays from scrimmage instead of 11. The chance of a significant injury had to be an order of magnitude higher than winning the game whether starting from 17 or 10 down.
Sometimes fans will misdirect their anger at their head coach over any negative outcome. I don’t think this is such a case.
Extended Treatment
Marlon Humphrey
- (Q1, 11:10): He was blocked by WR Evans as part of WR McMillan RL11 jet sweep
- (Q1, 4:02): He and Smith tackled McMillan PL8 (6 + 2) [2] on what appeared to be Stephens’ responsibility
- (Q2, 7:31): On 3rd/6, he was beaten by WR Godwin for PM15 (7 + 8) [3] but made the tackle
- (Q2, 6:17): On 2nd/3, he peeled off coverage of TE Otton to undercut WR McMillan for INT in endzone
- (Q2, 3:10): On 2nd/8, he made physical tackle of Godwin 9 yards [1] which would have dislodged the ball had it not already been dropped
- (Q2, 3:05): On 3rd/13, he stepped in front of Godwin 17 yards [5], collided with Wiggins, who was also trying to intercept, and held on after pinning the ball against his head for INT
Marlon’s plays on the ball this season have not only been critical in 2 of the last 3 wins but they give more credence to the notion he’ll be an outstanding safety when the time comes. Right now, he’s headed for a Pro Bowl year at safety if he can stay on the field.
Roquan Smith
- (Q1, 2:18): He was blocked by RG Mauch as part of RB Irving PL14 (-4 + 18) [2]
- (Q2, 10:14): He dropped to cover from LoS and was caught in wash unable to cover RB White PR13 (0 + 13) [5] but eventually pushed him OOB
- (Q2, 6:51): He shed RG Mauch in L2 to tackle RB Irving RR6
- (Q2, 4:23): He was blocked by C Barton in L2 as part of RB Tucker RL15
- (Q2, 3:48): He cleaned up on Van Noy’s MT to tackle Tucker RL2
- (Q3, 10:28): He cleaned up on Simpson’s MT to tackle WR McMillan PL0 (-3 + 3) [1]
- (Q3, 9:11): On 3rd/5, he took down Mayfield RM1 to force FG attempt
- (Q3, 2:12): On 3rd/6, he chased down Mayfield by the left sideline and drew a FM flag to deny conversion and set up 3rd/17
- (Q4, 12:45): On 3rd/11, he tackled TE Otton PR11 (6 + 5) [4] and dislodged the ball but Otton recovered/converted
- (Q4, 12:07): He hit WR Godwin while being blocked by C Barton which allowed Ngakoue/Urban to tackle PL9, avoiding a bigger play
- (Q4, 11:30): He was blocked by C Barton as part of RB White screen PL11 (-2 + 13) [2] TD
- (Q4, 3:46): He tackled RB White PL4 (-2 + 6) [1] inbounds
- (Q4, 3:03): On 3rd/1, he and Hamilton tackled White RM4 which allowed conversion with running clock
- (Q4, 1:04): On 3rd/17, he tackled Godwin PM21 (15 + 6) [4] which resulted in Godwin’s ankle injury
Roquan kept on hitting all game, did not have a missed tackle, and forced a fumble. Of his 18 tackle contributions 7 were defensive wins and he had 3 more that were losses but were inbounds and kept the clock running in the last 4 minutes. In coverage, he played well, but dropping to cover from the LoS compromised his ability to stay with his assignment, particularly on the 2nd play above. To date, the Ravens have played primarily QBs who are both aware and capable of leveraging that disadvantage.
Since week 3, he’s made 59 consecutive tackles and despite a rough start, he has a 5% MT rate for the season. The Ravens moved Kyle Hamilton to dime in W3. Given the questions of his first 2 years with the Ravens, maybe it’s time to ask if his play has been elevated by the departure of Queen. That’s a joke, folks. Roquan appears to be back on track for another All-Pro season.
Kyle Hamilton
- (Q1, 12:30): He made shoestring tackle of RB Irving RM4 to prevent cut outside, big gain
- (Q1, 3:38): He was blocked by pulling LT Wirfs in L2 as part of RB White RM7
- (Q1, 2:18): He assisted Jackson on clean up of RB Irving PL14 (-4 + 18) [2]
- (Q1, 1:37): He shed WR Godwin for ankle tackle of RB White PR2 (-4 + 6) [4] with 7 blockers in front of play
- (Q1, 1:01): He and Wiggins had WR Evans bracketed 13 yards [5] in endzone as Mayfield overthrew
- (Q1, 0:57): He was closest in EZ on Mayfield TD to Godwin PL8 negated by holding
- (Q1, 0:49): On 3rd/18, he had MT at 11 yards on Otton PM13 (-1 + 14) [2] cleaned up by Pierce/Van Noy to force FG
- (Q2, 8:58): He beat block from WR Shepard for shoestring tackle of Otton PR4 (-1 + 5) [4] to prevent big play
- (Q2, 4:23): He was blocked by TE Otton as part of RB Tucker RL15
- (Q4, 13:32): He delivered a hard shoulder-to-shoulder hit on Otton 20 yards [4] but ball was overthrown
- (Q4, 5:50): He made quick, hard tackle of Otton PR6 (5 +1) [4]
- (Q4, 3:03): On 3rd/1, he assisted Smith on tackle of RB White RM4 inbounds
- (Q4, 1:34): He reached past TE Otton 4 yards [5] for PD
- (Q4, 0:13): On game’s final play, he tackled Mayfield softly despite lack of slide for RM12
Kyle was second on the team with contributions to 11 tackles but missed just 1. Of his tackle contributions, 3 were part of defensive wins and 3 others were by the ankles in space and appeared to prevent big plays. He did not allow a single pass play of 10+ yards as a coverage player and only 21 total yards in total.
Nate Wiggins
- (Q1, 11:10): He ran across field to assist Smith on push of WR McMillan OOB on RL11
- (Q1, 1:01): He had bracket coverage of WR Evans in EZ 13 yards [5] as Mayfield overthrew
- (Q2, 3:05): On 3rd/13, he collided with Humphrey as both undercut Godwin 17 yards [5] and Humphrey intercepted
- (Q3, 5:52): He diagnosed choice route by WR Palmer and contested the catch for PD/near INT
- (Q3, 2:18): He dove to undercut McMillan 27 yards [5] and barely missed collecting INT, no PD credited
- (Q4, 5:32): He had tight coverage of McMillan 28 yards [5] as Mayfield’s pressured pass was underthrown
- (Q4, 2:18): He was flagged for illegal contact (declined) on WR Shepard PR15 (15 + 0) [5]
- (Q4, 2:12): He was beaten by McMillan 25 yards [5] but Mayfield’s throw forced OOB reception in EZ
- (Q4, 0:23): He undercut McMillan 15 yards [5] for PD/near INT
This was Nate’s best game as a pro. He starred in coverage despite the IC and is showing impressive ball skills which will eventually pay off with interceptions. He was bailed out when beaten by McMillan in the end zone, but Mayfield’s throw may have been impacted by his presence and he did not allow a single reception as I scored it.
Defensive MVPs
- Marlon Humphrey
- Roquan Smith
- Kyle Hamilton and Nate Wiggins
Honorable mention to Odafe Oweh, Tavius Robinson, and Ar’Darius Washington.n.
Love your work, but the Hamilton hit on Otton “ On the first play, TE Otton was laid out by Hamilton with a shoulder-to-shoulder hit for which Todd Bowles was visibly upset with the lack of a flag” happened on an earlier drive.
Glad you saw Wiggins as having good play. I thought I’d seen that but wasn’t sure. Like how he is rounding out in only his first year.